
HISTORICAL PERSON
Ma Su
马谡
Zhang He defeated Zhuge Liang’s commander Ma Su at Jieting by cutting off his access to water.
This entry is supported by historical references, but does not yet have a conversation profile.
PRIMARY BIOGRAPHY
Biography
Ma Su (190–228), courtesy name Youchang, was the youngest of the five talented Ma brothers of Xiangyang — “of the Five Constants of the Ma clan, the white-browed one is the best” said the village rhyme of his brother Ma Liang. Ma Su followed Liu Bei into Shu and governed Mianzhu, Chengdu, and Yuexi. Zhuge Liang prized his strategic talk and would discourse with him from dawn to night — against Liu Bei’s deathbed warning: “Ma Su’s words exceed his substance. Do not use him in great matters.”
In 225, seeing Zhuge Liang off for the southern campaign, Ma Su gave his famous counsel: “Nanzhong trusts in its distance and will rebel again tomorrow — attack the heart, not the walls; win their hearts and the south is won.” Zhuge Liang took the advice, pardoned Meng Huo seven times, and the south stayed quiet for the rest of Liang’s life.
In 228 Zhuge Liang overruled the generals and gave Ma Su the vanguard at Jieting. Ma Su abandoned the road and watered town to camp on the southern heights; Zhang He cut his water and destroyed him. The expedition collapsed. Zhuge Liang executed Ma Su — weeping as he did — and demoted himself three grades, telling Jiang Wan: “Sun Wu won because his law was clear. With the realm divided and war just begun, what use is an army without law?” Ma Su was thirty-nine; a hundred thousand men wept for him.
Life and role
- Primary role
- Staff officer of Shu Han
- Active period
- Late Han and Shu Han (200s–240s)
- Primary group
- Shu-Han
Affiliations across a lifetime
- 214–225
Shu — staff officer
Zhuge Liang’s favorite strategist; author of the “win hearts” policy for Nanzhong
- 228
Jieting
Broke orders, lost Jieting to Zhang He, executed at thirty-nine
HISTORICAL RECORD
Historical sources
- Records of the Three Kingdoms · Wei, Book 17 · Biographies of Zhang Liao, Le Jin, Yu Jin, Zhang He, and Xu Huang ↗
Chen Shou’s base text: biographies of Zhang Liao, Le Jin, Yu Jin, Zhang He, and Xu Huang, plus the attached account of Zhu Ling. Pei Songzhi’s annotations are registered separately.
- Records of the Three Kingdoms · Shu, Book 9 · 董刘马陈董吕传 ↗
Chen Shou’s base text contains the biographies of Dong He, Liu Ba, Ma Liang, Chen Zhen, Dong Yun (with Chen Zhi), and Lü Yi. Ma Su’s account is included in the narrative under Ma Liang, and Dong Yun’s account records his opposition to Huang Hao. The concluding evaluation is separate; Pei Songzhi’s annotations should be identified separately.