Three Kingdoms
← All events

231

Battle of Lucheng and the Death of Zhang He

In 231 Zhuge Liang’s fourth northern expedition fought Sima Yi around Mount Qi and Lucheng. The Han–Jin Chronicle says Zhuge Liang crushed Sima Yi’s army, taking three thousand armoured heads — the Book of Jin claims the opposite for Sima Yi, and both stand in the record. What is not disputed is the end: when supplies failed and Shu withdrew, Sima Yi ordered Zhang He to pursue against his protest, and the old general was killed by an arrow at Mumen. Within three years Zhuge Liang and Cao Rui would also be dead.

See the realm in 229 on the historical atlas

Who took part

Historical sources

  1. 汉晋春秋(裴松之注引) · 蜀书五·诸葛亮传注 ↗

    In 231 the Han–Jin Chronicle records Zhuge Liang crushing Sima Yi’s army at Lucheng, taking three thousand armoured heads and thousands of suits of mail; on the retreat, Wei’s veteran Zhang He was killed by an arrow at Mumen after Sima Yi ordered him to pursue.

  2. 魏略(裴松之注引) · 魏书十七·张乐于张徐传注 ↗

    In 231 Zhuge Liang withdrew from Lucheng and Sima Yi ordered Zhang He to pursue; Zhang He cited the rule — “a besieged city must be left an exit road; a returning army must not be pursued” — Sima Yi insisted, and Zhang He died in the Mumen ambush.

  3. 晋书 · 卷一·宣帝纪 ↗

    The Jin annals claim that in 231 Sima Yi struck Zhuge Liang at Lucheng and “pursued and broke him, taking or killing myriads” — flatly contradicting the Han–Jin Chronicle, which records Sima Yi worsted there; both versions stand in the sources.

  4. 三国志 · 魏书十七·张乐于张徐传 ↗

    Chen Shou’s text records the end plainly: pursuing Zhuge Liang’s retreating army to Mumen in 231, Zhang He fought and “a flying bolt struck him in the right knee, and he died” — the last of Wei’s five great generals gone in a pursuit he had opposed.

Ask Zhuge Liang about it